Harmans Lawyers
17 November 2026

Employment Court confirms offshore recruitment premiums are unlawful

All Articles & News, Employment Law

What is an employment premium (recruitment fee)?

Section 12A of the Wages Protection Act 1983 (“the Act”) prevents employers or their agents from charging a premium in respect of a person’s employment (“employment premium”).

Employment premiums are often seen in cases of migrant worker exploitation, where an employer may require a person to pay a fee to secure a job in New Zealand, or may try to pass on recruitment costs (for example, costs associated with verifying a potential employee’s qualifications). Typically, those fees can sit between $10,000 and $60,000 and are paid through intermediaries offshore.

Are premiums paid overseas unlawful in New Zealand?

In a landmark employment law decision, the Employment Court in Labour Inspector v Top Produce Ltd was asked to determine an important question: Are payments made outside New Zealand for employment within New Zealand caught by the Act’s prohibition on premiums?

The full bench of the Employment Court decisively determined that section 12A’s prohibition applies to all employment premiums, even if the payments are made outside New Zealand.  This decision overturned an earlier ruling (Mehta v Elliott) that held that section 12A did not apply to offshore transactions. The Court clarified that the law is meant to protect workers from exploitation, no matter where the payment occurs.

Why is this decision important?

Evidence presented in the case highlighted that offshore employment premiums have become a significant and calculated means of worker exploitation.  These practices often include informal transactions, debt bondage, and intermediaries acting on behalf of employers, further complicating regulation and enforcement.

This decision closes a significant loophole that previously allowed employers in New Zealand to avoid the section 12A prohibition by arranging offshore payments.  In doing so, the Court emphasised that the prohibition in section 12A was designed to create a robust protective framework for workers, particularly vulnerable migrant workers, and noted that its interpretation of the law aligns with New Zealand’s international commitments to labour standards, such as those under the International Labour Organisation (ILO).

Do premiums paid through relatives or agents count?

The Court also clarified that section 12A(2) of the Act allows for the recovery of premiums paid indirectly through intermediaries, such as relatives or agents acting on behalf of employers.  This prevents employers from hiding behind intermediaries to avoid responsibility.

The Court’s position was that employment laws should be interpreted in a way that supports international efforts to combat forced labour and exploitation.

What should you do?

If you are an employee who has been charged an employment premium to secure work in New Zealand, or an employer considering whether to require candidates to pay recruitment fees incurred or using an offshore agent or recruiter who requires candidates to pay recruitment fees, it is important that you seek legal advice regarding your rights and obligations.

Talk to the Employment team at Harmans Lawyers today on (03) 379 7835 / legal@harmans.co.nz.